I've eaten here enough to start losing count of how many times I've been. And despite having
enjoyed every morsel of food I've had here, I struggled with how to write this review. I love the food here. I'm an unabashed
Birch and Barley fan, and for that reason I don't want this review to be perceived as an unbiased rave because I happen to get along with Kyle and Tiffany, their executive chef and executive pastry chef. Full disclosure: I have enjoyed several perks in the past, like getting to try several new dishes on the house. But let's be real: if the food sucked, I'd never go back.
 |
| Beer Sampling at Birch and Barley |
Now that we got that out of the way, let's get on with a proper restaurant review. This review is somewhat lengthy because I've been so many times that I've tried so much of the menu!
With the arrival of summer, I headed to Birch and Barley looking forward to some substantial menu changes. I tend to be a creature of habit, and while I love the ricotta cavatelli, I was ready to try something new. To kick off the meal, I opted to go with the pisco punch cocktail which was refreshing with the right balance of tart and sweet. It goes without saying B&B is known for their enormous beer selection. I'd go into the beers I had there (I had a "carrot cake" and a "white russian" beer there that were two of the most unusual and cool beers I've ever had), but as a waiter once clued me in: you can try a beer there one time that you love, but it might never be on the menu again. The craft beers come from a variety of small breweries, thus limited quantities, thus jot down the name of a beer and ask your server about it if you really like one.
 |
| Shrimp & Chorizo Flatbread |
I've had the bread plate and the charcuterie plate a few times before and I got a sneak peek at the charcuterie closet in the restaurant (a foodie's dream come true!). The housemade pretzels with the grainy mustard are phenomenal with a dark brown shell and soft inside. The kalamata olive rolls and the foccacia are also great with melted butter. If you're down with cured meats, go for the butcher's board (um hello, beer and meat? Do I need to say more?). There aren't very many places I'll try something that has pig's head in it, but B&B is one.
Four other appetizers I got to try recently were the fig & prosciutto flatbread, the shrimp & chorizo flatbread, the seared baby sepia with squid ink farfalle and the grilled octopus. For the flatbreads, banish any notion that these are like pizzas. The thick crust is the right amount of chewiness for the toppings. I usually don't go for sweet and savory combinations, but the combination of sweet figs with salty prosciutto and gorgonzola are perfect. The housemade chorizo is just a little spicy. Plus the softer textures of the shrimp, romesco and chorizo went well with the crunch of the toasted almonds on the flatbread. As for the seared baby sepia (aka
cuttlefish), it was a good kind of chewy (not in a rubbery way). The black farfalle with the white cuttlefish and dark dandelion greens made for a nice presentation. Lastly for the appetizers, my friends and I tried the grilled octopus. Now I'm not entirely sure how it's prepared, but the octopus has this almost flakey texture, like fish. Forget any notions of rubbery octopus--this cut easily and went so well with the slightly crispy potatoes and fried capers (if you have never had a fried caper, you have not truly lived).
 |
| Farfalle and seared sepia |
 |
| Grilled octopus with fried capers |
For dinner I ordered the tempura jumbo soft shell crab, one of my most favorite pieces of seafood. The batter was light and went well with the buckwheat soba that took on the ponzu flavor. For me the ponzu and citrus flavors were great, though another friend remarked that her soft shell crab became overly saturated with ponzu as she worked her way through dinner. I also tried a bite of the prosciutto-wrapped veal--incredibly tender and the prosciutto was nice and crispy on the outside. None of us at the table could quite put our finger on what made the barley slightly sweet in that entree (one person guessed nutmeg); either way, it still tasted great.
 |
| Softshell crab with sobu noodles |
 |
| Veal with barley |
Here's one of the things I love about Birch & Barley--there is usually a dish with something in it that I'm not crazy about and ordinarily wouldn't order. Take for example, Kyle's beet risotto that was on the menu a few months ago. I hate beets. Pickled, canned, roasted, candied--I don't care how you make them, I will not enjoy eating them. Goat cheese and beet salad? Been there, done that (probably have wanted to spit it out into my napkin before). And then there was this beet risotto. It was a dish that came out compliments of Kyle, and so I thought, "Here goes nothing. I have to at least try this." Creamy with a subtle and sweet beet flavor, and the brightest, richest beet color. I was sold. Or the kale that had been sauteed to have the right balance between silkiness and the vibrant, fresh crunch of spring. Or Tiffany's peanut butter cheesecake? Again, you say cheesecake, I say I'll pass (with the exception of the manchego cheesecake at Estadio and the key lime cheesecake I had when I interviewed Mallory Staley at 1789). But this peanut buttery confection with the celery vanilla ice cream actually made me start to create positive memories of eating ants on a log back on 5th grade Girl Scout camping trips. What I'm saying is that the dishes at Birch & Barley often get me to think of ingredients in a new way. They make me wiggle out of my comfort zone and make me revise my opinions on foods I usually steer clear of. And that's not something that many chefs can do.
 |
| Tiffany MacIsaac's Dessert plate |
For dessert, I don't even know where to begin. If I had to sum up Tiffany's desserts in one word, I'd say playful. The cookies and confections plate as well as the ants on a log dessert demonstrate such creativity. Cereal milk sorbet with a pecan joy? Yes, please. Another favorite of mine was the oatmeal cream pie. Take a note from this woman's book, Little Debbie. Also, go for the spiced parsnip cake. I know, parsnip, root vegetable, what is it doing on a dessert menu? But trust me, it works. The panna cotta with flavors of hazelnut and chocolate go so well with the blood orange slices and sorbet. Do not dare go here and not save room for dessert.
 |
| Hazelnut panna cotta with blood orange sorbet |
So there you have it: my thoughts on Birch & Barley. I like going to a restaurant after having interviewed a chef, not for perks, but because I gain a greater appreciation for where they're coming from and what their thought process is behind their food. I like to learn more about a chef's approach to food, to their craft. I like to find out if they're actually passionate about what they do because I think that shows in their cooking. And if that makes me "biased" about their food, I'm kind of okay with that.